Discover your dream Career
For Recruiters

Morning Coffee: Banking VP sends 'brutal' email to analysts. The 1,000 people with the best jobs in finance

If you're a vice president (VP) in an investment bank today, think very carefully before you send an email.

In the new post-Goldman 13 world, the kind of disgruntled email that might once have simply provoked light retaliatory snarking, is now making its way to Instagram and beyond.

The latest email of the genre was purportedly sent last Friday by a VP at an independent U.S. investment bank who was fed-up with his juniors failing to amend a pitch document as per his mark-up. The fact that most of it is written in capitals suggests the VP is pretty annoyed. So do repetitive statements like: "IN THE FUTURE DO NOT STRAY FROM THE MARKUP EVER. YOU GUYS STRUGGLED WITH A MARKUP SHELL AND I SAID I WOULD MARK IT UP. THEN IT APPEARS DIDN'T FOLLOW IT... I DO NOT HAVE TIME TO BURN." [sic]

Ostensibly, the VP's comments seem pretty reasonable: if you have a team of analysts who don't know how to put a pitch together and you help them by showing them exactly what they should do, it must be frustrating when they ignore it. Worse, it seems that they included a page on pricing from another deal, which was supposed to have been left out. The VP even apologizes at the start for, "getting fired up."

Despite all this, and despite far worse emails being sent in the past (Eg. The PJT email asking why no one was responding to emails at 3am), the latest has made it to forum website Wall Street Oasis where it's described as "brutal." - "Absolutely insane that this is common in industry still," says the person posting it. "This guy seems to have a massive ego," suggests someone commenting. 

The implication is that the bar for VP to analyst communication has risen. These days, even if analysts screw-up, staff above them are expected to be sympathetic. If they're not, they may find themselves subject to public censure.

This places additional stress on VPs, who themselves are pulling long hours. VPs have to manage irascible directors and managing directors while gently chivying a team of exhausted analysts and associates who are already feeling unloved. That's not an easy role.

Friday's email also refutes the notion that junior bankers get to work autonomously on interesting tasks. "EVERYTHING I TELL YOU IS CALCULATED EVEN IF IT DOESN'T APPEAR AS SUCH," writes the VP. "PAY ATTENTION AND DO WHAT IS ASKED. THAT IS IT. NOTHING MORE, NOTHING LESS." The real adage for getting ahead in banking is simply: "Do what you're told."

Separately, Jane Street is not a listed company, but now and then figures leak out showing just how successful and profitable and therefore high paying it is. Bloomberg was the beneficiary of a leak like this on Friday: in 2020, it seems that the 'secretive trading house' made revenues of $10.6bn (up 54%) and Ebitda of $7.8bn (up 59%). It did this with a staff of around 1,000 people. Bloomberg notes that this means the average profit per employee at Jane Street last year was around $8m...


Santander has big expansion plans for its investment bank. "In Europe it is fair to say that we started being probably a tier two to tier three [investment bank]...The ambition is to be one of the leading European banks.” (Financial Times) 

Studying a Masters in finance at HEC Paris can nearly double your salary to $157k. (Financial Times) 

Tina Lee, CEO of Deutsche Bank UK and Ireland, wants investment banking graduate trainees in the office five days a week, although it won't be mandatory. "My personal view in terms of grads and interns is that they should want to spend as much time in the office as they possibly can." (Business Insider)

Deloitte UK says it will allow staff to decide, "when, where and how they work” after COVID. (The Guardian) 

Lanistar, a much hyped UK fintech has not paid its staff for months after its launch was delayed due to the pandemic. “We are in a tough place...people are genuinely suffering.” (Financial News)

Outgoing Bank of England governor Mark Carney receive £443,965 in salary, benefits, and pension contributions, and £113,821 in relocation expenses to move him and his family back to Ottawa in Canada. He only worked 14 full days last year. (Financial News) 

Sean George, a 'keen mixed martial artist' who once ran a martial arts gym, has become a portfolio manager at Grace Court Capital, a credit fund division of Millennium Capital Partners. (Fi-desk)

37% of staff at Deutsche Bank in the U.S. are women, but only 21% hold top jobs. (Bloomberg) 

Women need to start talking about the menopause. “Be clear if you’ve had a rubbish night’s sleep, because there will be lots of other women going through exactly the same thing.” (Bloomberg) 

Have a confidential story, tip, or comment you’d like to share? Contact: in the first instance. Whatsapp/Signal/Telegram also available. Bear with us if you leave a comment at the bottom of this article: all our comments are moderated by human beings. Sometimes these humans might be asleep, or away from their desks, so it may take a while for your comment to appear. Eventually it will – unless it’s offensive or libelous (in which case it won’t.)

Photo by Andre Hunter on Unsplash

AUTHORSarah Butcher Global Editor
  • Ka
    23 June 2021

    I mean, you hire privileged (90%+) kids from target schools. Give them their first real job in IB because they carry "prestige" and make them grind 80hr weeks consistently. Absolutely not surprised they fail at aligning logos here and then complain.

    For hardo students reading this, the average lifespan for an analyst in IB is just two-years. After taxes, you make slightly more than a good developer or data scientist while working 2x hours and causing more expensive damage to your body. Seriously, use those finance skills and just do the math here... Unless you're making it to PE, you're just drinking the kool-aid for one of the most overrated jobs that even girls at bars don't care for anymore

  • ju
    22 June 2021

    Was waiting to get to the 'brutal' part ....

    As a Millennial, trained by Boomers, and now managing Gen Z .. I feel this person's pain 😩

  • An
    22 June 2021

    What was the percentage of suitable female applicants for 'top jobs'?

  • Sa
    22 June 2021

    Incompetent staff and incompetent colleagues make excuses and cry foul when corrected. This is a common frustration for a lot of managers and also for a lot of colleagues who will cross check and correct colleagues mistakes to reduce lag in work.

  • Ro
    Rob Higgins
    22 June 2021

    This is what kids call "brutal" these days? Seriously?

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.

Boost your career

Find thousands of job opportunities by signing up to eFinancialCareers today.
Recommended Articles
Recommended Jobs
Deutsche Bank
Analyst- Trader
Deutsche Bank
Hong Kong
Morgan Stanley
Equity Trader
Morgan Stanley
NF Forensics Ltd
Equity Analyst (Forensic Accounting)
NF Forensics Ltd
London, United Kingdom
Logan Sinclair
Fundamental Equity Long/Short - Analyst
Logan Sinclair
London, United Kingdom
Platinum & Partners
Equity Sales Trader - High Touch
Platinum & Partners
London, United Kingdom
Client Lifecycle Management
London, United Kingdom

Sign up to Morning Coffee!

Coffee mug

The essential daily roundup of news and analysis read by everyone from senior bankers and traders to new recruits.